Yes, learning a new web tool is somewhat like arriving to a fancy Christmas Dinner late. The food is enticing, the guests are friendly, but you somehow you feel awkward and displaced. And besides, what is that dish, anyways?
One of the first steps Goodreads asks you to complete is to "find friends" via Gmail, Facebook, Twitter and some other options. I opted not to do this step at all when I noticed Goodreads wanted to search my contact list at Gmail (which seemed a little dubious), and also and more alarmingly, post to Facebook and Twitter 'on my behalf'. I feel very uncomfortable letting anybody but me post to my accounts. So, I guess I don't have any friends for the time being, and it raised some interesting questions for me about internet privacy and security.
Not wanting to feel defeated, I ventured further and started setting up my bookshelf. One of the first books I added was "One D
I'm looking forward to trying a new feature at GoodReads, the recommendation system, which requires members to rate at least 20 books before it generates a list of novel suggestions. I found an interesting blog at the New Yorker in which writer Macy Halford (2011) gives the recommendation feature a mixed review, arguing that although it generates some good suggestions, it doesn't take into account that "[b]ooks are messy and the reasons humans like them are messier". I'll have to try it out for myself.
Halford, M. (2011, September 19). Getting good at Goodreads [Web log post]. Retrieved from http://www.newyorker.com/online/blogs/books/2011/09/getting-good-at-goodreads-1.html
I am also looking at Good Reads this week (although my approach is to compare it to Shelfari and this morning I added Library Things). I didn't want to "find friends" either. I am still new to the whole social networking thing and I feel hesitant to join things...so I have no friends either! I will be interested to see what you discover this week! Have fun exploring!
ReplyDeleteHi Jen,
ReplyDeleteI too will be exploring personal online book catalogues. How did you decide to use Goodreads? I haven't made a choice yet on which one I will use. Looks like you are off to a good start! If I decide to use Goodreads, I too will be skipping the 'find friends' option. Are you able to sort books into categories you make yourself? I am hoping to create some lists of resources and picture books I teach with, and categorizing them would be very helpful.
Joclyn